Rumors from the front:
Apple likes to say their products “just work”, but their definition
of “works” seems to be a little different when it comes to the iPhone.
A recent visit to the Apple store by one New York iPhone owner ended
with a rather confusing diagnosis from the Apple Genius.
Manoj Gupta became frustrated with his iPhone’s propensity for
dropping calls. Suspecting there was something wrong, he had the local
Apple store run some tests. Luckily, the Genius reported that no
repairs were needed. However, that’s not to say nothing was wrong. The
phone dropped 22% of calls, which is totally normal for New York
apparently.
The report stated that most phones drop over 30% of calls. So
clearly, Mr. Gupta is downright lucky to only be dropping 22% of calls.
We’ve long heard that AT&T’s network is in a terrible state in New
York City, but has it really gotten this bad?
My enthusiasm for spending on money for an iPhone stuck with the AT&T network isn't all that great.
Update #1: David comments:
Yes. It is a problem. But the iPhone is more of a great gadget/device than a phone per se. I know people who get a Verizon phone to use as a reliable phone and also carry around an iPod Touch, which is basically an iPhone without the phone. But that's a lot of clutter to lug around. At least I get one device that works (mostly) like a phone and also handles podcasts, music, satellite radio, Japanese lessons and flashcards, medical database, to do list, appointments calendar, on line instant medication information, websurfing, text messaging and games (to keep kids from fighting in the backseat). And the screen resolution and OS for that part of the iPhone blows everything else away. So on the whole, I'm still happy and not planning on taking it back.
But I already have a first edition iTouch, though the wi-fi on it broke a few months ago. It would be nice to get web access, but I'm not going to pay for a 2nd phone.